Current:Home > ScamsWhy the power of a US attorney has become a flashpoint in the Hunter Biden case-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Why the power of a US attorney has become a flashpoint in the Hunter Biden case
View Date:2024-12-23 19:07:15
WASHINGTON (AP) — House Republicans grilled Attorney General Merrick Garland on Wednesday about the Justice Department investigation of Hunter Biden in a contentious hearing that delved into aspects of the criminal justice system that typically play out long before the case enters a public courtroom.
Many questions from members of Congress centered on the yearslong investigation of the president’s son, who has been under scrutiny for his business dealings and has now been indicted on a federal firearms charge alleging he lied about his drug use as he bought a gun in 2018.
Internal Revenue Service agents have claimed in whistleblower testimony the investigation was “slow walked” and the authority of the prosecutor in charge was curtailed by the Justice Department. Garland has strongly denied the allegations, but they could become a main line of attack as an impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden unfolds.
While the Hunter Biden case is far from typical, it touches on some of the more mundane but less-well-understood aspects of the criminal justice system.
Here are some common questions and answers about the workings of criminal prosecutions:
HOW DO CASES GET FILED?
In the federal court system, cases typically start with investigators at agencies like the FBI, Drug Enforcement Administration or Homeland Security. There are 94 U.S. Attorney’s Offices where prosecutors look at evidence and decide whether to file charges. Some cases turn into criminal charges, while in others prosecutors decline to proceed. Prosecutors typically have wide discretion about who to charge, how many charges to file, and how serious those charges should be — and they may differ from counts investigators cited in an arrest or investigation.
WHAT IF AN INVESTIGATION CROSSES ANOTHER STATE?
If authorities following leads in one case find allegations that cross into another state or jurisdiction and prosecutors want to file charges, there are at least two paths they can follow.
A U.S. attorney’s office can partner with counterparts in the other state and file the case together. If prosecutors in the other state decline to work together, a U.S. attorney can request permission to bring a case outside of his jurisdiction under what’s known at the Justice Department as a “515 order.”
The order – its name references a section of federal law – says the prosecutor has been directed to work in the other jurisdiction by the attorney general. Such an order, requiring approval in this case by Garland or another senior Justice Department official, gives the prosecutor what’s typically known as “special attorney” status.
In his testimony on Wednesday, Garland referred to that process as “very common” and “nothing cumbersome.”
In the Hunter Biden case, IRS agents have alleged that Delaware U.S. Attorney David Weiss, the prosecutor overseeing the case, was turned down by his counterparts in Washington and California when he wanted to file tax charges there. Republicans cite that as evidence that Weiss never had “full authority” to pursue the case. Garland acknowledged that U.S. attorneys can refuse to cooperate for reasons ranging from workload to their view of the strength of the case, but said that he quickly gave Weiss special status.
WHAT IS A SPECIAL COUNSEL?
A special counsel is an attorney who is appointed to investigate a case in which the Justice Department perceives itself as having a conflict or where it’s considered to be in the public interest to have someone outside the government come in and take responsibility.
This person is not subject to day-to-day supervision of the Justice Department, but must still comply with department regulations, policies and procedures. The attorney general is expected to give great weight to special counsels’ views, but can also seek explanations about any investigative or prosecutorial step they want to take. The attorney general retains final say and is the one government official who can fire them, but must notify Congress if a move the special counsel wants to make is rejected.
Republicans raised questions Wednesday about Weiss’s status as a special counsel appointed in August, saying a plea deal his office was ready to strike with Biden was a “sweetheart deal” and showed he wasn’t the best choice for the role. Garland, for his part, said he made the appointment because Weiss requested it and was leery of “changing horses midstream.”
He demurred on other questions about the timing of the decision, saying he didn’t want to share details of an ongoing investigation and had been purposely hands-off on the Hunter Biden probe in particular to avoid any perception of political interference.
WHAT ARE SOME OF THE COMPLICATIONS ON THE HUNTER BIDEN CASE?
Congressional Republicans have been investigating nearly every aspect of Hunter Biden’s business dealings, as well as the Justice Department’s handling of his case. Several federal investigators have testified to having differing views of Weiss’ authority in the waning months of the investigations late last year.
Gary Shapley, a veteran IRS agent who had been assigned to the case, testified to Congress in May that he heard Weiss say in a October 2022 meeting that he was not the “deciding person whether charges are filed” against Hunter Biden.
But in the past two weeks, senior FBI agents Thomas Sobocinski and his deputy — two of seven people in attendance — told lawmakers that they have no recollection of Weiss saying that.
“At no point did I think he did not have that authority to do all of those steps with all that we were looking at,” Sobocinski said. He added later in the interview, “I never thought that anybody was there above David Weiss to say no.”
veryGood! (7)
Related
- Britney Spears Reunites With Son Jayden Federline After His Move to Hawaii
- Ben Shelton's US Open run shows he is a star on the rise who just might change the game
- These Looks From New York Fashion Week's Spring/Summer 2024 Runways Will Make You Swoon
- Powerful ethnic militia in Myanmar repatriates 1,200 Chinese suspected of involvement in cybercrime
- Steelers shoot for the moon ball, but will offense hold up or wilt in brutal final stretch?
- Elon Musk and Grimes Have a Third Child, New Biography Says
- Mysterious golden egg found 2 miles deep on ocean floor off Alaska — and scientists still don't know what it is
- Sarah Ferguson Shares Heartwarming Update on Queen Elizabeth II's Corgis One Year After Her Death
- Mike Tyson-Jake Paul: How to watch the fight, time, odds
- The Rolling Stones set to release first new album of original music in nearly 20 years: New music, new era
Ranking
- Wendi McLendon-Covey talks NBC sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' and hospital humor
- Afghanistan is the fastest-growing maker of methamphetamine, UN drug agency says
- 'Not one child should be unaccounted for:' After Maui wildfires, school enrollment suffers
- As the Colorado River Declines, Some Upstream Look to Use it Before They Lose it
- John Robinson, former USC Trojans and Los Angeles Rams coach, dies at 89
- Vicky Krieps on the feminist Western ‘The Dead Don’t Hurt’ and how she leaves behind past roles
- 7 habits to live a healthier life, inspired by the world's longest-lived communities
- Judge denies Mark Meadows’ request to move his Georgia election subversion case to federal court
Recommendation
-
Driver dies after crashing on hurricane-damaged highway in North Carolina
-
In Aryna Sabalenka, Coco Gauff faces powerful, and complicated, opponent in US Open final
-
Soccer star Achraf Hakimi urges Moroccans to ‘help each other’ after earthquake
-
Stassi Schroeder Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 2 With Beau Clark
-
Kennesaw State football coach Brian Bohannon steps down after 10 seasons amid first year in FBS
-
Novak Djokovic steals Ben Shelton's phone celebration after defeating 20-year-old at US Open
-
Emotions will run high for Virginia as the Cavaliers honor slain teammate ahead of 1st home game
-
College football Week 2 highlights: Alabama-Texas score, best action from Saturday