Would Suits’ Sarah Rafferty Return for the L.A. Spinoff? She Says…

Sarah Rafferty may see herself in a brand new law firm.

Nearly a year after a Suits spinoff was greenlit, the OG cast member shared whether fans would see her in the new series. And the verdict? 

"If Donna is needed, I'm happy to put the shoes on," Sarah, who played the quick-witted secretary, told E! News in an exclusive interview. She quipped of her character's fashion, "I might need them to be a little shorter since it's been a long time after Covid."

The new series, Suits: L.A., is set in the same universe as the original series from 2011 to 2019 and will star Stephen Amell as star lawyer Ted Black alongside his protégé Rick Dodsen played by Bryan Greenberg.

The Suits finale ended with Donna Paulsen and former boss Harvey Specter (Gabriel Macht) finally getting married and moving to Seattle to work with Mike Ross (Patrick J. Adams) and his wife Rachel Zane (Meghan Markle). And Sarah would be interested in unfolding more of their relationship—if it feels right.  

As she put it, "If there is a reason to continue telling the story, there should be."

Where does she see Donna and Harvey now? Together, happy and still close friends with former colleague Louis Litt (Rick Hoffman).

"I'm sure she's happy in Seattle with her friends and her husband," the 51-year-old reflected. "She's still very tied to Louis' life, invested and has regular visits. She still supports them because she's the lady with the connections. When they need Donna, she's there to do that."

"I do wonder what she's pursuing in her career right now," she added. "She's definitely pursuing something with purpose and mission, and I wonder what that is."

But Sarah has plenty of time to ponder since she and Patrick teamed up for Sirius XM's Sidebar: A Suits Watch Podcast. And the project has given the pair a newfound respect for the show—and their collaborators like creator Aaron Korsh and costar Gina Torres.

"It's just such a joy to see my friends work the scenes that I wasn't there for," she said of the first few episodes they've watched so far. "I don't know about them, it's such a joy to ask them questions about it. It was amazing to talk to Gina about the development of Jessica Pearson and what her process had been with that. I think every episode will bring a new jewel, a new kind of amazing thing to discover."

And it's also given Sarah and Patrick an avenue to connect with longtime fans of the USA series, which ended in 2019 after nine seasons.

"We're getting incredible fan questions that spark amazing conversations, and we're so grateful for that," she said. "We're so grateful for the feedback about where they were, where the viewer was in their life and what it meant to them."

As Sarah and Patrick look back at their time at Pearson Hardman (and its multiple name changes), keep reading for more Suits secrets.

(E! and USA are both part of the NBCUniversal family.)

1. Truthfully, Suits creator Aaron Korsh didn't think he had much of a case when he shopped around his original script. As the writer's strike was ending in 2008, Korsh's agent suggested he turn his stories about former finance boss Harvey into a series. And as an aspiring comedy writer, he told The Hollywood Reporter, "I sat down to write something in the tone of Entourage that took place on Wall Street. What emerged when I was finished was an hourlong show. I wouldn't say it was a thriller, but it was much more dramatic, with these plot twists and turns."

Not expecting a winning verdict, he continued, "I certainly didn't think in a million years that anybody would buy this show. I was just trying to write a sample that someone would maybe read and hire me off."

Among the tweaks that were made when it was transformed into a pilot for USA: Protagonist Mike Ross (Patrick J. Adams) and co. were switched from a team of investment bankers to a group of high-powered attorneys. "It raised the stakes," Korsh acknowledged. Because now Mike, who hadn't graduated college, much less passed the bar, wasn't just lying his way into a lucrative gig, "he was committing a crime," said Korsh, "and the law also gave us opportunities for all kinds of ethical dilemmas."

2. Korsh objected to the network's other edits. In the first season they "wanted a case of the week, every week," he noted, revealing he often received notes instructing him to insert more scenes centered around that episode's client. 

"We'd add them and shoot them," he told THR, "and then I'd cut them out of the edit, and no one ever said, 'Put them back.' No one noticed! The next year, they were like, 'You know what? You don't need a case of the week.'"  

3. Welcome to New York? With only the pilot of the New York City-set series actually shot in the city, production had to get creative once they set up shop in Toronto. Two giant murals—one for daytime scenes, one for night—stood in for Manhattan's expansive vista, hanging behind all of the office sets.

Or, as Sarah Rafferty (legal secretary turned chief operating officer Donna Paulsen) put it in a clip posted to TikTok, "Basically, New York City is a gigantic shower curtain." 

4. Adams made quite the closing argument while auditioning for the part of ballsy college dropout Mike, who parlayed his photographic memory and law knowledge into a high-powered legal gig.

"I had been fired from a pilot and it was a pretty public firing," he said of the short-lived 2011 series Friends With Benefits. "And then you get to go into a room and look these producers in the eye and literally say these words to them in the audition: 'Give me this job. I promise I will not fail. I'll work harder than anybody you've ever seen.' Those are the easiest words that have ever left my mouth."

5. As for future duchess Meghan Markle, who scored the part of paralegal and future attorney Rachel Zane after gigs on The League and Without a Trace, she turned up to the audition in denim and a strappy top. Feeling a bit too casual, she relayed in her 2017 cover interview with Vanity Fair, she hit up a nearby H&M for a $35 LBD.

It proved to be a smart purchase as she was asked to slip into something dressier. But the true secret weapon for the star, who ended up in competition with actress Kim Shaw for the part, was her chemistry with Adams. As Jeff Wachtel, the chief content officer of NBC Universal Cable Entertainment, told THR: "They had it right away. It was a lot of fun."

6. It didn't hurt that Markle felt a strong connection to the hard-working aspiring lawyer. "Rachel and I are very similar: ambitious, driven, and always trying to take the bull by its horns," she detailed to Marie Claire in 2013. They also shared a tendency to beat themselves up ("I'm harder on myself than anyone else might be") and a love for farm-to-table fare.

"My character is a foodie because they know that I'm a foodie," noted Markle, who wore all her own jewelry in the series, including her grandmother's charm bracelet and her favorite signet ring. "I'm always on the quest to find amazing new restaurants and new recipes."

7. Gina Torres convinced casting directors to overturn their original plan to have her role—managing partner Jessica Pearson—go to a man. Retooled for the 24 alum, "What I brought to the table being a woman at that time in her 40s, who had been doing the thing she loves for over 20 years informed [Jessica]," she told Entertainment Weekly, adding she appreciated how "fully in her body" the Harvard grad was. 

"That is the biggest takeaway from playing that character," she explained, "and it made her scary to some people. It made her aspirational to other people, sometimes both."

8. It was almost a case closed situation when Torres (then wed to fellow actor Laurence Fishburn) decided to leave the show at the end of her contract in 2016. The plan, Korsh told The Hollywood Reporter, was for Jessica to move to Chicago with her boyfriend (D.B. Woodside) only to be murdered by an unhinged former client. "I didn't think we were going to see it; we were going to hear about it," he explained. "It was going to shatter everyone and we were going to do a two-year time jump afterwards."

The network objected, however, and "when we got into the writing of the episode, we just decided to let her have a happy ending," said Korsh. "And it does absolutely leave the door open for her to come back." Or...spin off into her own titular series. 

9. In a lot of ways, Gabriel Macht slipped right into the part of high-powered attorney Harvey Specter. "My sister is a former Assistant District Attorney in the Bronx," the NYC native explained to The TV Addict ahead of the 2011 premiere. "My aunt was in family law. One of my very close friends was a top corporate attorney in Los Angeles....And my cousin was also in family law, a divorce attorney. I've just been around it my whole life, so I've observed bits and pieces along the way. And I feel like when I get the scripts each week, I don't have to Wikipedia and try to figure out what all these terms mean." 

But he did voice objections to the shooting location ("I love the people of Toronto and I love our crew but New York is where the story is written and I think it should be shot there," he told Metro in 2012) and Harvey's overall look. "I find it to be icky and crispy," he said of his slicked-back hairstyle, "but it works for Harvey."

10. Despite fans' desires, pairing off managing partner Harvey with Rafferty's Donna was not a foregone conclusion in creator Korsh's mind. "When I wrote the pilot, I wasn't like, 'Harvey and Donna are destined to be together,' or even, 'Are they going to be the big "will they or won't they?"' But we definitely went through that with Mike and Rachel," he confessed to USA. "Do we keep them together, and what do we do about that?"

But, yes, he took note of the #Darvey shippers on social media, saying that "they're louder than the percentage who aren't" and feel "that they comprise 240 percent of viewers." Eventually, he gave in, ending the series with the pair's spontaneous wedding.

11. As for Macht and Rafferty IRL, "we go back 20 years and our daughters are best friends," the actor revealed in a 2012 interview with Blast magazine of teenage Satine (he and wife Jacinda Barrett are also parents to Luca) and teen Oona (Rafferty and husband Santtu Seppälä also have daughter Iris). "We are really, really, really close friends. We've been to each other's weddings."

12. Rick Hoffman would get, uh, Litt up by his furry costars. Though his character, managing partner Louis Litt, was fond of cats, Hoffman was so allergic that crew would have EpiPens and inhalers on hand when he had to film with one. 

13. While Mike had a photographic memory, Adams was in possession of some solid photo skills. The majority of the snaps in Rachel's office were captured by Adams, who shares other images on his Instagram page. 

14. Though the series gained an uptick in the court of public opinion after landing on Netflix in 2023, diehard Suitors have been there from the beginning. Olympian Michael Phelps made a cameo in season three and Charles Barkley was so devoted that he was willing to juggle a few balls to make an appearance in season five.

"It's really cool for me, because when they heard me bragging about the show they invited me and I was like, 'I gotta make it work,'" the former NBA power forward turned TNT sports analyst told THR. "Right now with playoffs we're in our busy time and the only day we have off is Friday. I was like, 'I don't give a s--t. My day off, we're going up there to Toronto.'"

15. As for Katherine Heigl, she admittedly courted creator Korsh to land a gig on the series for its last two seasons. "I totally pitched myself," she told E! News of scoring the role of new partner Samantha Wheeler, by reaching out to Korsh. "When he said, 'I'm going to be busy with the eighth season,' I was like, 'Really? Do you need anybody? 'Cause I'm available.'"

It was a pretty winning strategy, she acknowledged. "I'm going to do that all the time," she continued. "I'm just going to call everybody—the showrunners of all the shows I love—and be like, 'Do you need a new character?'"

16. Korsh bet hard on Markle becoming a princess bride. Though the actress didn't announce she was leaving Suits until after her November 2017 engagement, Korsh began making plans for her departure months earlier.

"I knew obviously from about a year ago that this relationship was burgeoning," he told The Telegraph at the time. "I didn't want to intrude, so I didn't want to ask, 'Hey, what's going on? What are you going to do?' As the season progressed, I said I would rather have good things happening to Meghan in her life, which would likely mean her leaving the show, so let's plan on that."

17. Appropriately, season seven's finale saw Markle's Rachel whisked away to Seattle by her prince charming—and the opportunity to run their own law firm. But the pair were initially meant to wed two seasons earlier before Mike began his prison sentence.

"In the original script we were getting married, and all of us we're kind of like…it just felt a little cheesy to me, when we were all reading it," Adams explained to E! News. "But everybody was ready to do it, and I just thought, this is so much in an episode. Like, I'm going to get married and I'm going to go to jail, it just felt like we were packing it all in."

Eventually, he continued, Korsh caught wind of the chatter and decided to make a last-minute edit. Said Adams, "It felt a lot more important to say no to the wedding. So it was a day before that we got the new pages that it wasn't a wedding."

18. The entire cast, uh, suited up for Markle's big day. "We all went as a family," Korsh noted. "When we all went, there were about 10 of us or something...it was unbelievable."

And there was no chance of any of them RSVPing no.

"We worked together for so many years on the show. It's such an amazing experience. We were with each other for longer than we went to college or high school with our friends," explained Rafferty. "We became family, in a way; we're still family. So, this is a wonderful family affair."