Current:Home > StocksLawsuit against North Carolina officer who shot and killed teen can continue, court says-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Lawsuit against North Carolina officer who shot and killed teen can continue, court says
View Date:2024-12-23 14:39:39
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — The mother of a 17-year-old who was killed while driving a reportedly stolen car in a central North Carolina city can continue to pursue claims against the police officer who shot her son, a federal court has ruled.
A three-judge panel for the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Virginia, unanimously reversed on Monday a previous decision by a lower court to dismiss civil claims — including use of excessive force in the shooting death of the Black teenager, Nasanto Crenshaw — against Greensboro city police officer Matthew Lewis Sletten.
The lawsuit against the officer now returns to the U.S. District Court in Greensboro, where it may go to trial. The panel, meanwhile, upheld the dismissal of other claims against the city contained in the lawsuit.
After responding to reports of a stolen car in August 2022, Sletten followed the vehicle, which Crenshaw was driving, until they reached a dead end in the parking lot, according to the appeals court’s ruling. Sletten attempted to block off the car with his patrol vehicle, which Crenshaw swiped while trying to park, according to the plaintiff.
The lawsuit said Crenshaw tried evading Sletten by driving off when the officer shot at the vehicle several times, fatally hitting the teen. Sletten told the court that Crenshaw drove “directly toward” him and caused him to shoot, according to the court ruling.
The teen’s mother, Wakita Doriety, sued the city and Sletten for wrongful death, battery and assault, in addition to claims against the officer for federal civil rights violations. She sought financial damages and other relief for his estate.
U.S. District Judge Catherine Eagles dismissed Doriety’s claims in July 2023 against both the city and Sletten after reviewing video footage of what happened. Calling the video “integral” to granting the officer’s motion to dismiss, Eagles ruled that the footage indisputably showed the car driving at Sletten, according to the appellate opinion.
The appellate panel only partially disagreed with Eagles’ ruling. Circuit Judge Barbara Milano Keenan, writing the court’s opinion, said the video didn’t clearly refute the plaintiff’s “plausible allegations” of excessive force at this stage in the litigation. Keenan wrote that the video lacked “critical details” such as where the officer was located, the trajectory of the allegedly stolen vehicle and distance between the car and Sletten when he fired his gun.
“Courts must be mindful not to short-circuit at the motion to dismiss stage a plaintiff’s plausible claim of excessive force based on a video that does not blatantly contradict those allegations,” she wrote. Circuit Judges James Wynn and DeAndrea Gist Benjamin joined in the opinion.
The plaintiff’s attorney, Harry Daniels, said in a statement that Sletten was not in danger when he shot Crenshaw, adding that he hopes Crenshaw’s mother will “get to have her day in court” because of the appellate ruling.
Attorneys from a Greensboro law firm representing Sletten declined to comment Tuesday. The ruling can still be appealed.
The Guilford County district attorney said last year she would not pursue criminal charges against Sletten, saying he was justified in using deadly force.
The panel did uphold the lower court’s decision to dismiss the case against the city by citing governmental immunity — a type of immunity for local governments to protect them from legal claims based on their employees’ actions.
veryGood! (551)
Related
- Video ‘bares’ all: Insurers say bear that damaged luxury cars was actually a person in a costume
- Greece becomes first Orthodox Christian country to legalize same-sex civil marriage, adoption
- Cómo migrantes ofrecen apoyo a la población que envejece en Arizona
- Pioneering Skier Kasha Rigby Dead in Avalanche at 54
- My Chemical Romance returns with ‘The Black Parade’ tour
- NBA All-Star Game highlights: East dazzles in win over West as Damian Lillard wins MVP
- Bryce Harper wants longer deal with Phillies to go in his 40s, accepts move to first base
- Celebrate Presidents Day by learning fun, interesting facts about US presidents
- USMNT Concacaf Nations League quarterfinal Leg 1 vs. Jamaica: Live stream and TV, rosters
- Trump hawks $399 branded shoes at 'Sneaker Con,' a day after a $355 million ruling against him
Ranking
- MVSU football player killed, driver injured in crash after police chase
- $1 million reward offered by Australian police to solve 45-year-old cold case of murdered mom
- Why Francesca Farago and Jesse Sullivan Want to Have Kids Before Getting Married
- Minnesota police seek motive as town grieves after 2 officers, 1 firefighter fatally shot
- Wisconsin’s high court to hear oral arguments on whether an 1849 abortion ban remains valid
- Jessie James Decker Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 4 With Husband Eric Decker
- Jaromir Jagr’s return to Pittsburgh ends with his No. 68 being retired — and catharsis
- Feds Deny Permits for Hydro Projects on Navajo Land, Citing Lack of Consultation With Tribes
Recommendation
-
Why Josh O'Connor Calls Sex Scenes Least Sexy Thing After Challengers With Zendaya and Mike Faist
-
How a Northwest tribe is escaping a rising ocean
-
Take a Look at the Original Brat Pack Then and Now, Nearly 40 Years After The Breakfast Club
-
Sylvester Stallone hired Navy SEALs to train daughters before they moved to New York City
-
J.Crew Outlet Quietly Drops Their Black Friday Deals - Save Up to 70% off Everything, Styles Start at $12
-
George Santos sues Jimmy Kimmel, says TV host fooled him into making embarrassing videos
-
Death and redemption in an American prison
-
All the Candid 2024 People's Choice Awards Moments You Didn't See on TV