Current:Home > Contact-usJudge rejects Justice Department's request to pause order limiting Biden administration's contact with social media companies-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Judge rejects Justice Department's request to pause order limiting Biden administration's contact with social media companies
View Date:2024-12-23 23:08:37
Washington — A federal judge on Monday turned down a Justice Department request to temporarily pause an order that blocks top Biden administration officials and several agencies from contacting social media companies, rejecting the government's claims that the injunction was too broad and threatened to chill lawful conduct.
U.S. District Judge Terry Doughty, appointed to the federal bench by former President Donald Trump, reiterated in a 13-page ruling denying the Justice Department's request for a stay that Missouri and Louisiana were likely to succeed on the merits of their case against the Biden administration.
"Although this Preliminary Injunction involves numerous agencies, it is not as broad as it appears," Doughty wrote. "It only prohibits something the Defendants have no legal right to do — contacting social media companies for the purpose of urging, encouraging, pressuring, or inducing in any manner, the removal, deletion, suppression, or reduction of content containing protected free speech posted on social-media platforms."
Missouri and Louisiana, he said, "are likely to prove that all of the enjoined defendants coerced, significantly encouraged, and/or jointly participated [with] social-media companies to suppress social-media posts by American citizens that expressed opinions that were anti-COVID-19 vaccines, anti-COVID-19 lockdowns, posts that delegitimized or questioned the results of the 2020 election, and other content not subject to any exception to the First Amendment. These items are protected free speech and were seemingly censored because of the viewpoints they expressed."
Following the denial by Doughty, the Justice Department asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit to pause the lower court's order pending appeal and is requesting relief by July 24.
"The district court issued a universal injunction with sweeping language that could be read to prohibit (among other things) virtually any government communication directed at social-media platforms regarding content moderation," Justice Department lawyers wrote. "The court's belief that the injunction forbids only unconstitutional conduct, while protecting the government's lawful prerogatives, rested on a fundamentally erroneous conception of the First Amendment, and the court's effort to tailor the injunction through a series of carveouts cured neither the injunction's overbreadth nor its vagueness."
Doughty issued the July 4 order limiting communications between the Biden administration and social media companies, including Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, as part of a lawsuit brought by the attorneys general of Louisiana and Missouri in 2022.
The states, joined by several individuals, claimed senior government officials colluded with the companies to suppress viewpoints and content on the social media platforms, in violation of the First Amendment.
The preliminary injunction blocks a number of top Biden administration officials — among them Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra, Surgeon General Vivek Murthy and White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre — from engaging in a range of communications with social media companies.
The administration officials, as well as several federal agencies, are temporarily prohibited from working with the companies in ways that are aimed at "urging, encouraging, pressuring, or inducing in any manner for removal, deletion, suppression, or reduction of content containing protected free speech."
But the order includes several carve-outs and allows the administration to inform social media companies of posts involving criminal activity, threats to national security and public safety, and illegal efforts to suppress voting or of foreign attempts to influence elections.
The Biden administration is appealing Doughty's ruling, but asked him to put the decision on hold while proceedings continue. Justice Department lawyers argued the order is too broad and unclear as to who it covers and what conduct it allows. They also warned the order issued last week would "chill a wide range of lawful government conduct."
- In:
- Social Media
veryGood! (988)
Related
- How to Build Your Target Fall Capsule Wardrobe: Budget-Friendly Must-Haves for Effortless Style
- Child's body confirmed by family as Mattie Sheils, who had been swept away in a Philadelphia river
- New Mexico Wants it ‘Both Ways,’ Insisting on Environmental Regulations While Benefiting from Oil and Gas
- Women now dominate the book business. Why there and not other creative industries?
- U.S.-Mexico water agreement might bring relief to parched South Texas
- Pete Davidson Enters Rehab for Mental Health
- Activists Take Aim at an Expressway Project in Karachi, Saying it Will Only Heighten Climate Threats
- Vivek Ramaswamy reaches donor threshold for first Republican presidential primary debate
- Ranked voting will decide a pivotal congressional race. How does that work?
- A career coach unlocks the secret to acing your job interview and combating anxiety
Ranking
- Man who stole and laundered roughly $1B in bitcoin is sentenced to 5 years in prison
- Inside Clean Energy: In Illinois, an Energy Bill Passes That Illustrates the Battle Lines of the Broader Energy Debate
- 5 things to know about Saudi Arabia's stunning decision to cut oil production
- Why Do Environmental Justice Advocates Oppose Carbon Markets? Look at California, They Say
- Joel Embiid injury, suspension update: When is 76ers star's NBA season debut?
- The one and only Tony Bennett
- Jaden Smith Says Mom Jada Pinkett Smith Introduced Him to Psychedelics
- How Greenhouse Gases Released by the Oil and Gas Industry Far Exceed What Regulators Think They Know
Recommendation
-
AIT Community Introduce
-
The loneliness of Fox News' Bret Baier
-
In Philadelphia, Mass Transit Officials Hope Redesigning Bus Routes Will Boost Post-Pandemic Ridership
-
Elon Musk says NPR's 'state-affiliated media' label might not have been accurate
-
Watch as massive amount of crabs scamper across Australian island: 'It's quite weird'
-
Surprise discovery: 37 swarming boulders spotted near asteroid hit by NASA spacecraft last year
-
Earthjustice Is Suing EPA Over Coal Ash Dumps, Which Leak Toxins Into Groundwater
-
Facebook users can apply for their portion of a $725 million lawsuit settlement