Current:Home > MarketsFederal judge blocks Texas' SB4 immigration law that would criminalize migrant crossings-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Federal judge blocks Texas' SB4 immigration law that would criminalize migrant crossings
View Date:2025-01-12 17:08:30
Eagle Pass, Texas — A federal judge in Austin on Thursday blocked Texas state officials from implementing a sweeping immigration law that would have allowed them to arrest, jail and prosecute migrants who cross into the U.S. illegally.
The Justice Department and the American Civil Liberties Union had challenged the law known as SB4, which was set to take effect on Tuesday, March 5.
In a 114-page order, Judge David Ezra of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas granted the challengers' request for a preliminary injunction preventing Texas officials from enforcing the state law.
Ezra wrote that the Constitution and Supreme Court precedent make clear that states cannot enforce immigration measures without federal approval, and that the Texas law conflicts with federal law. He rejected an argument from Texas that the state's authority to repel an "invasion" allows it to enforce SB4, writing that "surges in immigration do not constitute an 'invasion' within the meaning of the Constitution." Lastly, he said that allowing Texas to enforce the law would mean states could override federal statutes, a discredited constitutional theory known as nullification.
"[T]o allow Texas to permanently supersede federal directives on the basis of an invasion would amount to nullification of federal law and authority — a notion that is antithetical to the Constitution and has been unequivocally rejected by federal courts since the Civil War," Ezra wrote.
In a statement, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott vowed to "immediately appeal this decision, and we will not back down in our fight to protect our state — and our nation — from President Biden's border crisis." Attorney General Ken Paxton soon filed notice with the court that the state was appealing the ruling.
The appeal will come before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, which could pause the district judge's decision while it reviews the case. Either party could ultimately ask the Supreme Court to review the appeals court's action.
Abbott noted that "[e]ven from the bench, this District Judge acknowledged that this case will ultimately be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court." The high court could agree to hear the case, or let the lower court's ruling stand as the final word on the issue.
What SB4 would do
Crossing into the U.S. outside of a port of entry is already illegal under federal law, but the Texas law would've criminalized the action at the state level. It would allow state law enforcement officials to stop and detain anyone suspected of entering Texas unlawfully and empower state judges to issue de facto deportation orders.
While Texas troopers have already been arresting some migrant adults who cross the U.S.-Mexico border on state trespassing charges, that effort has required the consent of private property owners. SB4 would not.
Under the law, crossing into Texas illegally from Mexico would be treated as a misdemeanor crime, punishable by up to 180 days in jail and a fine of up to $2,000. Illegal reentry into Texas would be a felony offense, punishable with up to 2, 10 or 20 years in jail, depending on whether the migrant in question had been previously deported or convicted of certain crimes.
SB4 includes a provision that bars state officials from arresting migrants in certain locations, including schools, places of worship and health care facilities.
The law would also allow Texas magistrates to order migrants suspected of committing the new illegal entry or reentry crimes to return to Mexico as an alternative to continuing their prosecution. Those found to violate those orders could be charged with a second-degree felony.
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, a Republican, signed SB4 into law, arguing it's needed to deter illegal border crossings. More than 2 million migrants were apprehended by U.S. Border Patrol agents along the southern border in both fiscal years 2022 and 2023, the highest levels on record.
But the Biden administration said the state law interferes with federal immigration enforcement. Other critics of the measure have also said it could lead to racial profiling and overwhelm county jails and public safety resources.
Camilo Montoya-GalvezCamilo Montoya-Galvez is the immigration reporter at CBS News. Based in Washington, he covers immigration policy and politics.
TwitterveryGood! (8)
Related
- Waymo’s robotaxis now open to anyone who wants a driverless ride in Los Angeles
- Stellantis recalls over 15,000 Fiat vehicles in the US, NHTSA says
- Garland says officers’ torture of 2 Black men was betrayal of community they swore to protect
- Ryan Reynolds' Deadpool mocks Marvel movies in exclusive deleted scene
- The Fate of Hoda Kotb and Jenna Bush Hager's Today Fourth Hour Revealed
- Why Julianne Hough Sees Herself With a Man After Saying She Was Not Straight
- Unprecedented Numbers of Florida Manatees Have Died in Recent Years. New Habitat Protections Could Help Them
- Federal lawsuit challenging mask ban in suburban New York county dismissed
- Judge set to rule on whether to scrap Trump’s conviction in hush money case
- Judge directs NYC to develop plan for possible federal takeover of Rikers Island jail
Ranking
- ‘Heretic’ and Hugh Grant debut with $11 million, but ‘Venom: The Last Dance’ tops box office again
- Channing Tatum and Jenna Dewan's divorce nears an end after 6 years
- It's not just fans: A's players have eyes on their own Oakland Coliseum souvenirs, too
- Artem Chigvintsev breaks silence on his arrest after prosecutors decide not to charge him
- SNL's Chloe Fineman Says Rude Elon Musk Made Her Burst Into Tears as Show Host
- Presidents Cup TV, streaming, rosters for US vs. International tournament
- 'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' star Eduardo Xol dies at 58 after apparent stabbing
- Chiefs' Andy Reid, Patrick Mahomes explain Travis Kelce’s slow start
Recommendation
-
Jon Gruden joins Barstool Sports three years after email scandal with NFL
-
Presidents Cup TV, streaming, rosters for US vs. International tournament
-
Gil Ramirez remains on 'Golden Bachelorette' as Joan hits senior prom. Who left?
-
NASA, Boeing and Coast Guard representatives to testify about implosion of Titan submersible
-
Armie Hammer Says His Mom Gifted Him a Vasectomy for His 38th Birthday
-
Tommy John surgery is MLB's necessary evil 50 years later: 'We created this mess'
-
Tech tips to turn yourself into a Google Workspace and Microsoft Office pro
-
Pregnant Brittany Mahomes Shares “Best Picture” Ever Taken of Husband Patrick and Son Bronze