Current:Home > ScamsAlabama objects to proposed congressional districts designed to boost Black representation-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Alabama objects to proposed congressional districts designed to boost Black representation
View Date:2024-12-23 14:16:45
MONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — The Alabama attorney general’s office said Thursday that it opposes all three congressional maps proposed by a court-appointed special master as federal judges begin drawing new lines to create a second majority-Black district in the state or something close to it.
The attorney general’s office objected to the proposals, maintaining “that the districts based on this structure are unconstitutional racial gerrymanders.”
Plaintiffs in the case wrote that two of the plans are acceptable. The plaintiffs, who won before the U.S. Supreme Court twice this year in the redistricting case, objected to the third plan and said the suggested district would continue to be mostly won by white candidates.
The three-judge panel had asked the two sides to weigh in on the proposed new districts ahead of a hearing next week.
Evan Milligan, the lead plaintiff in the case said Tuesday that the Supreme Court’s decision will allow the state to have fair districts.
A group of Black voters and advocacy organizations challenged the state’s existing congressional plan in 2021. Plaintiffs had argued Alabama racially gerrymandered congressional lines so that Black voters were unable to influence elections outside of the state’s single majority-Black district.
A three-judge panel later found the state illegally diluted the voting strength of Black voters and ordered new districts drawn for the state. The panel is also stepping in to draw the new lines after Republican lawmakers defied their finding that Alabama — which is 27% Black — should have a second-majority Black district or something “close to it.”
The three proposals, submitted Sept. 25 by the court-appointed special master, would alter the boundaries of Congressional District 2 in south Alabama so that Black voters comprise between 48.5% to 50.1% of the voting age population.
The plaintiffs urged the court to adopt either proposed Plan 1 or Plan 3, saying that those adequately remedy the Voting Rights Act violation. They said the special master’s analysis concluded that the Black-preferred candidate would have won election in 15 or 16 out of 17 contests.
Plaintiffs objected to Plan 2 and said it “fails to reliably provide Black voters an opportunity to elect a candidate of their choice.” They said an analysis shows that it would continue to elect candidates backed by white voters.
“A district where the Black-preferred candidate wins only one of five times (20%) in the most recent congressional election cannot be considered an opportunity district,” plaintiffs wrote.
The judges asked the special master to file a response to the objection by Monday.
“An argument that it is needed to guarantee a win by the candidate of choice of black voters is inconsistent with the language of Section 2, which merely requires an equally open process,” the state attorney general’s office wrote.
The three-judge panel earlier this month chided state lawmakers, writing that they were “deeply troubled” lawmakers flouted their instruction to create a second majority-Black district or something close to it.
The U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled against the state in June, on Tuesday rejected Alabama’s request to put the re-draw on hold and let the state keep using a map with a single-majority Black district. Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall said the state will continue to appeal.
veryGood! (124)
Related
- Georgia House Republicans stick with leadership team for the next two years
- Live updates | Timing for the Israel-Hamas pause in fighting will be announced in the next 24 hours
- Student Academy Awards — a launching pad into Hollywood — celebrate 50 years
- Travis Kelce inspires Chipotle to temporarily change its name after old Tweets resurface
- Just Eat Takeaway sells Grubhub for $650 million, just 3 years after buying the app for $7.3 billion
- India in G20 summit welcomes Israel-Hamas cease-fire, urges action on climate, other issues
- What can trigger an itch? Scientists have found a new culprit
- Police say 2 dead and 5 wounded in Philadelphia shooting that may be drug-related
- Steelers shoot for the moon ball, but will offense hold up or wilt in brutal final stretch?
- Phoenix man gets 22 years in prison for nearly a dozen drive-by shootings
Ranking
- Britney Spears reunites with son Jayden, 18, after kids moved in with dad Kevin Federline
- Utah gymnastics parts ways with Tom Farden after allegations of abusive coaching
- Pilot dies after small plane crashes in Plano, Texas shopping center parking lot: Police
- Cryptocurrency exchange Binance pleads guilty along with CEO to money laundering charges
- Homes of Patrick Mahomes, Travis Kelce burglarized, per reports
- Albania’s prime minister calls for more NATO troops in neighboring Kosovo following ethnic violence
- Travis Kelce inspires Chipotle to temporarily change its name after old Tweets resurface
- Travis Kelce Thanks Taylor Swift and Her Fans for Helping His and Jason Kelce's Song Reach No. 1
Recommendation
-
What Republicans are saying about Matt Gaetz’s nomination for attorney general
-
India in G20 summit welcomes Israel-Hamas cease-fire, urges action on climate, other issues
-
A Las Vegas high school grapples with how a feud over stolen items escalated into a fatal beating
-
Travis Kelce inspires Chipotle to temporarily change its name after old Tweets resurface
-
Black, red or dead: How Omaha became a hub for black squirrel scholarship
-
Get used to it: COVID is a part of the holidays. Here's how to think about risks now
-
Missouri driver killed in crash involving car fleeing police
-
Niall Horan says he 'might pass out' on 'The Voice' from Playoffs pressure: 'I'm not OK'