Current:Home > Contact-usRetired Australian top judge and lawyers rebut opponents of Indigenous Voice-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Retired Australian top judge and lawyers rebut opponents of Indigenous Voice
View Date:2024-12-23 14:06:43
CANBERRA, Australia (AP) — A former High Court chief justice and dozens of legal academics on Friday rebutted key arguments used in the public campaign against Australians creating an advocacy body for the Indigenous population.
Robert French, who retired as Australia’s most senior judge in 2017, used a speech to the National Press Club to urge Australians to vote to enshrine in the constitution a so-called Indigenous Voice to Parliament at an Oct. 14 vote, the nation’s first referendum in a generation.
The Voice is aimed at giving Australia’s most disadvantaged ethnic minority more say on government policies that effect their lives.
“A vote in favor of the Voice is a new beginning and something in which this generation and generations to come should be able to take justifiable pride,” French said.
Separately, 71 Australian university teachers of constitution law and other fields of public law signed an open letter published Friday that rebutted the argument that the Voice would be “risky.”
“We know that the vast majority of expert legal opinion agrees that this amendment is not constitutionally risky,” the letter said.
Peak legal, business, faith and sporting groups overwhelmingly support the Voice. But opinion polls suggest most Australians do not, and that the nation’s first referendum since 1999 will fail.
If the referendum does pass, it would be the first to do so since 1977 and the only one in the 122-year history of the constitution to be carried without the bipartisan support of the major political parties.
French said he rejected the “No” campaign’s argument that an “over-speaking Voice might deluge all and sundry in executive government with its opinions.”
French said the Parliament could decide how the Voice made recommendations to government. He also rejected arguments that courts could force a government to act on the Voice’s suggestions or bind Parliament to take the Voice’s advice before making laws.
The “No” case cites another retired High Court Justice, Ian Callinan, who argues that legal uncertainty surrounding the Voice would lead to more than a decade of litigation.
French said Callinan’s “gloomy prognosis” was not probable.
“I couldn’t say there won’t be litigation,” French said. “It’s a matter of assessing the risk against the return. I see the risk as low — very low — compared with the potential benefits of the outcome.”
Legal risk and the potential for the constitution to divide Australians along racial lines are major objections to the Voice raised by conservative opposition parties.
Voice opponents include conservatives who argue the change is too radical, progressives who argue the change is not radical enough, and people who exhibit blatant racism.
A self-described progressive opponent of the Voice, independent Aboriginal Sen. Lidia Thorpe, circulated among the news media on Thursday an online white supremacist video that targets her by name.
In the video, a man disguised by a ski mask burns an Aboriginal flag before giving a Nazi salute.
Thorpe blamed Prime Minister Anthony Albanese for inspiring far-right extremists by holding the referendum.
“The referendum is an act of genocide against my people,” Thorpe told reporters Thursday.
Albanese said “there is no place in Australia” for such far-right demonstrations.
Indigenous Australians account for 3.8% of Australia’s population. They have worse outcomes on average than other Australians in a range of measures including health, employment, education and incarceration rates. Statistically, Indigenous Australians die around eight years younger than the wider community.
veryGood! (16315)
Related
- U.S.-Mexico water agreement might bring relief to parched South Texas
- Costco is selling dupe of luxury Anthropologie mirror, shoppers weigh in on social media
- Democrats believe abortion will motivate voters in 2024. Will it be enough?
- Full transcript of Face the Nation, Jan. 21, 2024
- Amazon Best Books of 2024 revealed: Top 10 span genres but all 'make you feel deeply'
- Homicide rates dropped in big cities. Why has the nation's capital seen a troubling rise?
- Saudi Arabia won’t recognize Israel without a path to a Palestinian state, top diplomat says
- YouTubers Cody Ko and Kelsey Kreppel Welcome First Baby
- RHOP's Candiace Dillard Bassett Gives Birth, Shares First Photos of Baby Boy
- The art of Trump's trials: Courtroom artist turns legal battles into works of art
Ranking
- Democrat Ruben Gallego wins Arizona US Senate race against Republican Kari Lake
- Taiwan says 6 Chinese balloons flew through its airspace, and warplanes and ships also detected
- Roxanna Asgarian's 'We Were Once a Family' and Amanda Peters' 'The Berry Pickers' win library medals
- I Look Like I Got Much More Sleep Than I Actually Did Thanks to This Under Eye Balm
- Utah AD Mark Harlan fined $40,000 for ripping referees and the Big 12 after loss to BYU
- 43 years after the end of the Iran hostage crisis, families of those affected still fight for justice
- The Doobie Brothers promise 'a show to remember' for 2024 tour: How to get tickets
- Homicide rates dropped in big cities. Why has the nation's capital seen a troubling rise?
Recommendation
-
Dick Van Dyke says he 'fortunately' won't be around for Trump's second presidency
-
Haley to launch ad targeting Trump's handling of North Korea relationship and hostage Otto Warmbier
-
Man arrested near Taylor Swift’s NYC townhouse after reported break-in attempt
-
Justin Timberlake debuts new song 'Selfish' at free hometown concert, teases 2024 album
-
'Devastation is absolutely heartbreaking' from Southern California wildfire
-
Nikki Haley goes on offense against Trump days before New Hampshire primary
-
Marlena Shaw, legendary California Soul singer, dies at 81
-
Marlena Shaw, legendary California Soul singer, dies at 81