Current:Home > FinanceLouisiana, 9 other states ask federal judge to block changes in National Flood Insurance Program-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Louisiana, 9 other states ask federal judge to block changes in National Flood Insurance Program
View Date:2024-12-23 18:24:54
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Increases in federal flood insurance premiums that are projected to surpass 700% over the coming years are already leading people to back out of home purchases and will likely lead to an exodus of residents and businesses from southern Louisiana, officials told a federal judge Thursday in New Orleans.
The testimony came in a hearing in a lawsuit Louisiana and nine other states filed against the federal government to block sharp increases in national flood insurance rates. A phase-in of the new rates began in 2021. Annual increases are limited to 18%. The Federal Emergency Management Agency said the new method of computing rates has resulted in reductions or little or no increase for most policy holders.
But FEMA figures also show huge impending increases in some Louisiana ZIP codes. State and local officials who testified Thursday said the increases are expected to result in some people in working-class southern Louisiana to abandon their mortgages, try to sell homes that have been in families for generations, or drop their insurance.
“We’ve already seen a slowdown in new building,” said Matt Jewell, president of St. Charles Parish, west of New Orleans.
The implications go beyond blows to the real estate market and tax revenue. Officials said lower revenue could also hamper flood prevention and mitigation efforts. And some federal disaster programs require people in certain areas to have flood insurance — which the officials argued is becoming unaffordable.
State attorneys said during arguments before U.S. District Judge Darrel Papillion that participation in the National Flood Insurance Program requires that local governments adopt building-elevation policies and flood-control efforts that often require taxes — approved by voters believing the mitigation efforts will hold rates down.
“They turned us into liars,” state Solicitor General Liz Murrill told Papillion.
Papillion was hearing arguments on the federal government’s motion to dismiss the suit and on the states’ motion for an injunction blocking the rate increases pending further court proceedings. It was unclear if he would rule Thursday.
Florida, Idaho, Kentucky, Mississippi, Montana, North Dakota, South Carolina, Texas and Virginia are the other states listed as plaintiffs, along with some local governments and flood control bodies in Louisiana.
FEMA has said its new premium system is an improvement over past methods, incorporating data that wasn’t used in the past, including scientific models and costs involved in rebuilding a home. The agency has said the old method could result in people with lower-valued homes paying more than a fair share, while those with higher-value homes pay relatively less.
A return to the old system of calculating premiums would not guarantee a reduction of rates, Justice Department attorney Yoseph Desta argued.
He and other government attorneys argued Thursday that the new rate plan had been in the works for years, that the states had plenty of opportunity for input, and that the lawsuit, filed months after the phase-in began, was filed too late. They also argued the states have no standing to sue over the rates set by the National Flood Insurance Program.
veryGood! (23122)
Related
- Bohannan requests a recount in Iowa’s close congressional race as GOP wins control of House
- Ryan Reynolds Confirms Sex of His and Blake Lively’s 4th Baby
- Victor Wembanyama leads France over Brazil in 2024 Paris Olympics opener
- From hating swimming to winning 10 medals, Allison Schmitt uses life story to give advice
- Shocked South Carolina woman walks into bathroom only to find python behind toilet
- Andy Murray pulls off unbelievable Olympic doubles comeback with Dan Evans
- Divers Sarah Bacon and Kassidy Cook win Team USA's first medal in Paris
- New ‘Dexter’ sequel starring Michael C. Hall announced at Comic-Con
- As the transition unfolds, Trump eyes one of his favorite targets: US intelligence
- 3 Members of The Nelons Family Gospel Group Dead in Plane Crash
Ranking
- Wall Street makes wagers on the likely winners and losers in a second Trump term
- Team USA cyclist Chloe Dygert wins bronze medal in individual time trial
- 'Olympics is going to elevate all of us:' Why women's volleyball could take off
- Focused amid the gunfire, an AP photographer captures another perspective of attack on Trump
- Zendaya Shares When She Feels Extra Safe With Boyfriend Tom Holland
- Nevada attorney general appeals to state high court in effort to revive fake electors case
- USA vs. New Zealand live updates: Score, time, TV for Olympic soccer games today
- Antoine Dupont helps host country France win first gold of 2024 Olympics
Recommendation
-
A wayward sea turtle wound up in the Netherlands. A rescue brought it thousands of miles back home
-
Everything we know about Simone Biles’ calf injury at Olympic qualifying
-
Paris Olympics are time to shine for Breanna Stewart, A'ja Wilson: 'We know what's at stake'
-
USA Shooting comes up short in air rifle mixed event at Paris Olympics
-
The Fate of Hoda Kotb and Jenna Bush Hager's Today Fourth Hour Revealed
-
Watching the Eras Tour for free, thousands of Swifties 'Taylor-gate' in Munich, Germany
-
Don’t Miss Old Navy’s 50% off Sale: Shop Denim Staples, Cozy Cardigans & More Great Finds Starting at $7
-
Joe Biden is out and Kamala Harris is in. Disenchanted voters are taking a new look at their choices