Current:Home > StocksA divided federal appeals court won’t revive Texas online journalist’s lawsuit over 2017 arrest-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
A divided federal appeals court won’t revive Texas online journalist’s lawsuit over 2017 arrest
View Date:2024-12-23 20:23:52
A divided federal appeals court refused on Tuesday to revive the lawsuit of a Texas-based online citizen journalist who said she was wrongfully arrested for seeking and obtaining nonpublic information from police in a case that drew attention from national media organizations and free speech advocates.
A state judge dismissed the criminal case against Priscilla Villarreal — known online as La Gordiloca — saying the law used to arrest her in 2017 was unconstitutional. But Villarreal still wanted to sue officials for damages. She lost Tuesday in a 9-7 decision from the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which saw strong dissents from a group of ideologically diverse judges appointed by Republican and Democratic presidents.
The majority held that the police officers and other officials Villarreal sued in Laredo and Webb County were entitled to legal immunity.
“Villarreal and others portray her as a martyr for the sake of journalism. That is inappropriate,” Judge Edith Jones wrote for the majority. “She could have followed Texas law, or challenged that law in court, before reporting nonpublic information from the backchannel source.”
The ruling included lengthy opinions covering more than 50 pages from three of the seven dissenting judges.
The law, according to court records, defined the criminal “misuse of official information” as using information that “has not been made public ... with intent to obtain a benefit or with intent to harm or defraud another.” Authorities had argued that Villarreal could benefit from using the information — the identities of a person who killed himself and a family involved in a car accident — to gain fame on her Facebook page, Lagordiloca News LaredoTx.
“If the First Amendment means anything, surely it means that citizens have the right to question or criticize public officials without fear of imprisonment,” Judge James Ho, nominated to the court by former President Donald Trump, said in one dissent. Other dissenters included three more nominees of Republican presidents, and three nominated by Democrats.
Villarreal and an attorney who represented her said in an email that they would take the case to the Supreme Court.
“I’m disappointed,” Villarreal said, “but I’m going to keep up the fight for my rights and those of all Americans.”
veryGood! (6916)
Related
- Moana 2 Star Dwayne Johnson Shares the Empowering Message Film Sends to Young Girls
- Get $103 Worth of Tatcha Skincare for $43.98 + 70% Off Flash Deals on Elemis, Josie Maran & More
- Tech consultant testifies that ‘bad joke’ led to deadly clash with Cash App founder Bob Lee
- Catholic bishops urged to boldly share church teachings — even unpopular ones
- NFL coaches diversity report 2024: Gains at head coach, setbacks at offensive coordinator
- John Krasinski Details Moment He Knew Wife Emily Blunt Was “the One”
- Volunteer firefighter accused of setting brush fire on Long Island
- GreenBox Systems will spend $144 million to build an automated warehouse in Georgia
- US overdose deaths are down, giving experts hope for an enduring decline
- GM recalls 460k cars for rear wheel lock-up: Affected models include Chevrolet, GMC, Cadillac
Ranking
- Timothée Chalamet Details How He Transformed Into Bob Dylan for Movie
- Rep. Michael McCaul of Texas says he was detained in airport over being ‘disoriented’
- Jana Kramer’s Ex Mike Caussin Shares Resentment Over Her Child Support Payments
- Daniele Rustioni to become Metropolitan Opera’s principal guest conductor
- Indiana man is found guilty of murder in the 2017 killings of 2 teenage girls
- 2 credit unions in Mississippi and Louisiana are planning to merge
- Drone footage captures scope of damage, destruction from deadly Louisville explosion
- Get well, Pop. The Spurs are in great hands until your return
Recommendation
-
Supreme Court seems likely to allow class action to proceed against tech company Nvidia
-
Cold case arrest: Florida man being held in decades-old Massachusetts double murder
-
Where is 'College GameDay' for Week 12? Location, what to know for ESPN show
-
Hurricane forecasters on alert: November storm could head for Florida
-
Wendi McLendon-Covey talks NBC sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' and hospital humor
-
Watch a rescuer’s cat-like reflexes pluck a kitten from mid-air after a scary fall
-
LSU student arrested over threats to governor who wanted a tiger at college football games
-
Just Eat Takeaway sells Grubhub for $650 million, just 3 years after buying the app for $7.3 billion