Current:Home > NewsJudge’s ruling temporarily allows for unlicensed Native Hawaiian midwifery-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Judge’s ruling temporarily allows for unlicensed Native Hawaiian midwifery
View Date:2024-12-23 22:31:18
HONOLULU (AP) — A Hawaii judge has temporarily blocked the state from enforcing a law requiring the licensing of practitioners and teachers of traditional Native Hawaiian midwifery while a lawsuit seeking to overturn the statute wends its way through the courts.
Lawmakers enacted the midwife licensure law, which asserted that the “improper practice of midwifery poses a significant risk of harm to the mother or newborn, and may result in death,” in 2019. Violations are punishable by up to a year in jail, plus thousands of dollars in criminal and civil fines.
The measure requires anyone who provides “assessment, monitoring, and care” during pregnancy, labor, childbirth and the postpartum period to be licensed.
A group of women sued, arguing that a wide range of people, including midwives, doulas, lactation consultants and even family and friends of the new mother would be subject to penalties and criminal liability.
Their complaint also said the law threatens the plaintiffs’ ability to serve women who seek traditional Native Hawaiian births.
Judge Shirley Kawamura issued a ruling late Monday afternoon barring the state from “enforcing, threatening to enforce or applying any penalties to those who practice, teach, and learn traditional Native Hawaiian healing practices of prenatal, maternal and child care.”
Plaintiffs testified during a four-day hearing last month that the law forces them to get licensed through costly out-of-state programs that don’t align with Hawaiian culture.
Ki‘inaniokalani Kahoʻohanohano testified that a lack of Native Hawaiian midwives when she prepared to give birth for the first time in 2003 inspired her to eventually become one herself. She described how she spent years helping to deliver as many as three babies a month, receiving them in a traditional cloth made of woven bark and uttering sacred chants as she welcomed them into the world.
The law constitutes a deprivation of Native Hawaiian customary rights, which are protected by the Hawaii constitution, Kawamura’s ruling said, and the “public interest weighs heavily towards protecting Native Hawaiian customs and traditions that are at risk of extinction.”
The dispute is the latest in a long debate about how and whether Hawaii should regulate the practice of traditional healing arts that date to well before the islands became the 50th state in 1959. Those healing practices were banished or severely restricted for much of the 20th century, but the Hawaiian Indigenous rights movement of the 1970s renewed interest in them.
The state eventually adopted a system under which councils versed in Native Hawaiian healing certify traditional practitioners, though the plaintiffs in the lawsuit say their efforts to form such a council for midwifery have failed.
The judge also noted in her ruling that the preliminary injunction is granted until there is a council that can recognize traditional Hawaiian birthing practitioners.
“This ruling means that traditional Native Hawaiian midwives can once again care for families, including those who choose home births, who can’t travel long distances, or who don’t feel safe or seen in other medical environments,” plaintiff and midwife trainee Makalani Franco-Francis said in a statement Wednesday. “We are now free to use our own community wisdom to care for one another without fear of prosecution.”
She testified last month how she learned customary practices from Kahoʻohanohano, including cultural protocols for a placenta, such as burying it to connect a newborn to its ancestral lands.
The judge found, however, that the state’s regulation of midwifery more broadly speaking is “reasonably necessary to protect the health, safety, and welfare of mothers and their newborns.”
The ruling doesn’t block the law as it pertains to unlicensed midwives who do not focus on Hawaiian birthing practices, said Hillary Schneller, an attorney with the Center for Reproductive Rights, which represents the women. “That is a gap that this order doesn’t address.”
The case is expected to continue to trial to determine whether the law should be permanently blocked.
The state attorney general’s office didn’t immediately respond to an email seeking comment on the ruling Wednesday.
veryGood! (497)
Related
- Beyoncé has released lots of new products. Here's a Beyhive gift guide for the holidays
- Derek Chauvin was stabbed 22 times in federal prison attack, according to new charges
- Review: The long Kiss goodbye ends at New York’s Madison Square Garden, but Kiss avatars loom
- Why Kirby Smart thinks Georgia should still be selected for College Football Playoff
- To Protect the Ozone Layer and Slow Global Warming, Fertilizers Must Be Deployed More Efficiently, UN Says
- Inside the fight against methane gas amid milestone pledges at COP28
- An Israeli raced to confront Palestinian attackers. He was then killed by an Israeli soldier
- Vermont day care provider convicted of causing infant’s death with doses of antihistamine
- A herniated disc is painful, debilitating. How to get relief.
- Lacking counselors, US schools turn to the booming business of online therapy
Ranking
- Unexpected pairing: New documentary tells a heartwarming story between Vietnam enemies
- No. 8 Alabama knocks off No. 1 Georgia 27-24 for SEC title. Both teams await postseason fate
- Phoenix officials reiterate caution when hiking after 3 mountain rescues in 1 day
- Who voted to expel George Santos? Here's the count on the House expulsion resolution
- Bohannan requests a recount in Iowa’s close congressional race as GOP wins control of House
- Duke basketball’s Tyrese Proctor injured in Blue Devils’ loss to Georgia Tech
- In Dubai, Harris deals with 2 issues important to young voters: climate and Gaza
- Why Kate Middleton Is Under More Pressure Than Most of the Royal Family
Recommendation
-
Darren Criss on why playing a robot in 'Maybe Happy Ending' makes him want to cry
-
Feeling alone? 5 tips to create connection and combat loneliness
-
The Excerpt podcast: The temporary truce between Israel and Hamas is over
-
Fiery crash on New Hampshire interstate sets off ammunition
-
Garth Brooks wants to move his sexual assault case to federal court. How that could help the singer.
-
Assailant targeting passersby in Paris attacked and killed 1 person and injured another
-
Israel says more hostages released by Hamas as temporary cease-fire holds for 7th day
-
Romanian guru suspected of running international sex sect handed preliminary charges with 14 others