Current:Home > MyWisconsin Supreme Court agrees to hear governor’s lawsuit against GOP-controlled Legislature-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Wisconsin Supreme Court agrees to hear governor’s lawsuit against GOP-controlled Legislature
View Date:2024-12-23 18:18:13
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — The Wisconsin Supreme Court on Friday agreed to hear Democratic Gov. Tony Evers’ lawsuit against the Republican-controlled Legislature arguing that it is obstructing basic government functions.
The court’s liberal majority agreed to hear the case, with the three conservative justices dissenting. It set oral arguments for April 17.
The court only agreed to immediately hear one of the three issues Evers brought forward in the complaint. That issue relates to the Legislature’s Republican-controlled budget committee blocking funding for state conservation programs.
Evers had also challenged a committee made up of legislative leaders not approving pay raises for University of Wisconsin employees. But after the lawsuit was filed, the panel did approve the raises. Evers had also challenged a legislative committee blocking updates to the state’s commercial building standards and ethics standards for licensed professionals.
The court said it was keeping both of those issues on hold pending a future order.
Liberal justices Janet Protasiewicz, Rebecca Dallet, Jill Karofsky and Ann Walsh Bradley agreed to take the case. Conservative Chief Justice Annette Ziegler and justices Brian Hagedorn and Rebecca Bradley dissented.
Rebecca Bradley, in her dissent, accused the majority of “needlessly engulfing this court in the morass of politics.”
“By accepting only one of the issues raised by the Governor and holding the other two issues in abeyance, the majority refashions this court as the Governor’s avenue for imposing policy changes without the consent of the governed,” she wrote. “When the majority’s political allies say jump, the new majority responds: ‘How high?’ ”
Hagedorn, who dissented separately, said the case was consequential and questioned taking it directly rather than have facts established through proceedings in lower courts first.
“A decision in this case could occasion a historic shift — both in the operation of state government, and in how this court interprets the boundary lines between the branches of government,” Hagedorn wrote. “Thoughtful lower court decisions usually improve the clarity of our work by framing the arguments and telling the parties what worked and what didn’t.”
Evers and the Republican legislative leaders Assembly Speaker Robin Vos and Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu did not return messages seeking comment.
Evers argued in the lawsuit that committees controlled by a few Republican lawmakers are being used by the Legislature to “reach far beyond its proper zone of constitutional lawmaking authority.”
Evers cites the Legislature’s budget-writing committee’s rejection of dozens of conservation projects selected by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources under the Knowles-Nelson Stewardship Program. Republicans have long been critics of the program, which protects land from development.
LeMahieu dismissed the lawsuit as frivolous at the time it was filed, saying in a statement that Evers was “working to diminish the voice of Wisconsinites by limiting the authority of the legislature and unduly strengthening his own administration.”
Evers and the GOP-controlled Legislature have been at odds from the moment Evers was elected in November 2018. He has issued more vetoes than any other Wisconsin governor, including blocking numerous bills changing how elections would be run in the key presidential battleground state.
The Legislature convened a lame duck session just weeks before Evers took office to weaken the incoming governor’s powers. They have repeatedly rejected appointees Evers has made to boards and commissions, including firing a majority of the Natural Resources Board in October.
In another sign of their strained relationship, Evers has rarely met with Republican legislative leaders. Evers is in the second year of his second term.
The Wisconsin Supreme Court flipped to majority liberal control in August. In December, it struck down Republican-drawn legislative maps on a 4-3 decision. The Evers lawsuit is one of several high-profile cases filed by Democrats since the court’s majority changed.
veryGood! (245)
Related
- Rachael Ray Details Getting Bashed Over Decision to Not Have Kids
- Two tons of meth disguised as watermelon seized at border; valued over $5 million
- Headlined by speech from Jerome Powell, Fed's Jackson Hole symposium set to begin
- College football Week 0 kicks off and we're also talking College Football Playoff this week
- Tom Brady Admits He Screwed Up as a Dad to Kids With Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bündchen
- $1M verdict for teen, already a victim when she was assaulted by an officer
- Housing market showing glimmers of hope amid grim reports
- National Public Data confirms massive data breach included Social Security numbers
- Drone footage captures scope of damage, destruction from deadly Louisville explosion
- Vermont police officer facing charge of aggravated assault during arrest
Ranking
- Texas now tops in SEC? Miami in trouble? Five overreactions to college football Week 11
- Too early or not soon enough? Internet reacts to Starbucks dropping Pumpkin Spice Lattes Aug. 22
- Donald Trump addresses AI Taylor Swift campaign photos: 'I don't know anything about them'
- US home sales ended a 4-month slide in July amid easing mortgage rates, more homes on the market
- Prosecutor failed to show that Musk’s $1M-a-day sweepstakes was an illegal lottery, judge says
- Justice Department accuses RealPage of violating antitrust laws through scheme to hike rents
- An Iceland volcano erupts again but spares the nearby town of Grindavik for now
- Joey Lawrence Accused of Cheating on Wife Samantha Cope With Actress Melina Alves in Divorce Docs
Recommendation
-
Should Georgia bench Carson Beck with CFP at stake against Tennessee? That's not happening
-
$1M verdict for teen, already a victim when she was assaulted by an officer
-
Transgender Texans blocked from changing their sex on their driver’s license
-
BMW recalls over 720,000 vehicles due to water pump malfunction that may cause a fire
-
NFL overreactions: New York Jets, Dallas Cowboys going nowhere after Week 10
-
FACT FOCUS: A look back at false and misleading claims made during the the Democratic convention
-
College Football season is about to kick off. Here are our record projections for every team
-
Stranger Things' Priah Ferguson Talks Finale & Bath & Body Works Drop—Including an Eddie’s Jacket Candle