Current:Home > NewsOil Pipelines or Climate Action? Trudeau Walks a Political Tightrope in Canada-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Oil Pipelines or Climate Action? Trudeau Walks a Political Tightrope in Canada
View Date:2024-12-23 16:22:31
Can the owner of a tar sands pipeline be a climate change champion? Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is, improbably, trying to make that case.
In its biggest move yet to boost the nation’s oil industry, Trudeau’s government announced this week that it’s buying a major oil pipeline from Kinder Morgan for CA$4.5 billion and pressing ahead with controversial plans to expand it. The project is seen as critical to the growth of Canada’s tar sands industry, among the world’s most carbon-intensive sources of oil.
The new pipeline would make it cheaper to extract more of this oil, and yet Trudeau told Bloomberg News after the announcement that the project is also key to his government’s effort to cut emissions, which relies on a degree of support from Alberta and its oil-dominated economy.
“In order to be able to protect our environment, we do need to be able to have a strong and growing economy,” he said. “That’s why our plan to fight climate change features both a national price on pollution, things like the world class oceans protection plan, but also getting our oil resources to new markets through responsible pipelines.”
The problem is that expanding production of Alberta’s tar sands, also called oil sands, collides head on with Canada’s commitment under the 2015 Paris climate agreement to cut its emissions 30 percent below 2005 levels by 2030.
“If you’re putting in this pipeline, you’re creating a very stable, low-cost means of transporting oil, and that sends a signal to markets, to investors, to the world, that Canada’s going to continue pumping oil,” said Peter Erickson, a senior scientist at the Stockholm Environment Institute.
In a report published last week, Erickson writes that expanding Canada’s oil sands production could effectively cancel out any efforts the country makes to reduce emissions.
The Trans Mountain Pipeline Fight
Kinder Morgan announced plans to expand its Trans Mountain line six years ago, but it quickly met opposition along the route, which runs from Alberta to the Pacific coast. Climate change activists, indigenous First Nations and the British Columbia government say the project, which would nearly triple capacity of the existing pipeline up to 890,000 barrels per day, not only runs against Canada’s climate pledges but also could lead to oil spills and threaten industries like fishing and recreation.
Last month, the company announced it would abandon the project unless the Canadian government could guarantee a smooth road to completion.
Pipelines have become increasingly difficult to build in Canada, and the lack of new capacity is starting to crimp the industry’s profits because companies are relying increasingly on shipping by rail, which is more expensive. This bottleneck has made completing new pipelines, like the Trans Mountain expansion, a priority for the Canadian government.
The oil and gas industry is already responsible for about a quarter of Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions, though. If it continues growing as planned, the sector’s share would increase significantly, requiring drastic cuts elsewhere if the climate pledges are to be kept.
The environmental advocacy group Oil Change International said that unless tar sands output is restricted, Canadian oil would end up emitting about one-sixth of the global carbon budget allowed if warming is to be kept to 1.5 degrees Celsius.
“There’s no way of spinning the math that makes that okay,” climate activist Bill McKibben wrote in an article published by the Guardian after the government announced it would buy Trans Mountain. McKibben co-founded the advocacy group 350.org and is among the most active opponents of new oil sands pipelines. In a tweet, he called Trudeau “the new face of global warming.”
Eriel Deranger, executive director of the Canadian advocacy group Indigenous Climate Action, called Trudeau’s decision “an affront on the rights of Indigenous communities and a giant step backwards in achieving Canada’s climate commitments.”
Canada’s Paris Climate Plan Needs Alberta
Canada’s climate plan includes setting a national price on carbon, and it required support from Alberta, home to most of the tar sands and other oil and gas development.
But Alberta’s buy-in was built on a promise that the federal government would approve some new pipelines out of the province, said Richard Masson, an executive fellow at the University of Calgary’s School of Public Policy and former chief executive of the Alberta Petroleum Marketing Commission, an arm of provincial government.
Alberta’s economy is highly dependent on oil and gas, and provincial leaders who are seen as insufficiently supportive could get voted out. Without the pipelines, Masson and others say, the climate bargain could fall apart.
That reasoning implies that Canada will fall short of its climate goals no matter what.
“Will we meet our goals? I doubt it,” Masson said. “But if we don’t do this, the alternative is probably doing much less.”
veryGood! (4)
Related
- Pete Alonso's best free agent fits: Will Mets bring back Polar Bear?
- 9/11 memorial events mark 22 years since the attacks and remember those who died
- Lahaina high school team pushes ahead with season to give Maui community hope
- Texas is back? Alabama is done? College football overreactions for Week 2
- Inflation ticked up in October, CPI report shows. What happens next with interest rates?
- Bosnia court confirms charges against Bosnian Serb leader Dodik for defying top international envoy
- Man confessed to killing Boston woman in 1979 to FBI agents, prosecutors say
- Boy’s body found after jet ski collision with barge that also killed father
- California teen pleads guilty in Florida to making hundreds of ‘swatting’ calls across the US
- Michigan Catholic group wins zoning fight over display of Stations of the Cross
Ranking
- Detroit-area police win appeal over liability in death of woman in custody
- Hostess stock price soars after Smucker reveals plans to purchase snack maker for $5.6B
- Josh Duhamel and Wife Audra Mari Duhamel Expecting First Baby Together
- Demi Lovato revealed as mystery mouse character on 'The Masked Singer': Watch
- Father, 5 children hurt in propane tank explosion while getting toys: 'Devastating accident'
- Stolen van Gogh painting worth millions recovered by Dutch art detective
- France, Bangladesh sign deal to provide loans, satellite technology during Macron’s visit to Dhaka
- Wheel comes off pickup truck, bounces over Indianapolis interstate median, kills 2nd driver
Recommendation
-
Kraft Heinz stops serving school-designed Lunchables because of low demand
-
Sheriff in New Mexico’s most populous county rejects governor’s gun ban, calling it unconstitutional
-
Kia, Volkswagen, Subaru, and Audi among 208,000 vehicles recalled: Check car recalls here
-
Trial begins over Texas voter laws that sparked 38-day walkout by Democrats in 2021
-
Fire crews gain greater control over destructive Southern California wildfire
-
Western Balkan heads of state press for swift approval of their European Union membership bids
-
Heavy rain brings flash flooding in parts of Massachusetts and Rhode Island
-
Lighthouse where walkway collapse injured visitors to remain closed for indefinite amount of time