Current:Home > InvestIn UAW strike, Trump pretends to support workers. He's used to stabbing them in the back.-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
In UAW strike, Trump pretends to support workers. He's used to stabbing them in the back.
View Date:2024-12-23 16:15:45
In an unusual move, Donald Trump has announced plans to speak in Detroit this Wednesday, evidently seeking some political benefit from the autoworkers’ strike, saying he has always had workers' backs.
The former president is unarguably seeking to woo Michigan workers. But Michigan’s workers – indeed, all workers – should remember that in his four years as president, Trump and his administration did far more to stab workers in the back than to have their backs.
Trump rolled back Obama-era protections that would have extended overtime pay to millions more workers. He didn’t lift a finger to raise the federal minimum wage, which has remained at a low $7.25 an hour since 2009.
His administration pushed to ease safety requirements for oil rig workers and relax rules for safety inspections in coal mines. Trump also eliminated the ban on a toxic pesticide, chlorpyrifos, that causes acute reactions in farmworkers and does nerve damage to children.
Trump boasted repeatedly of his huge infrastructure plans, trumpeting one infrastructure week after another. But that became a running joke as he, unlike President Joe Biden, utterly failed to enact an infrastructure plan and create the jobs that many construction workers were eager for.
Trump got one important piece of legislation through Congress: $1.5 trillion in tax cuts that went overwhelmingly to the rich and corporations, while giving peanuts to typical workers like the UAW members on strike.
Copycat Joe?Trump plans visit with Michigan UAW workers, Biden scrambles to do the same.
Don't be fooled, Trump doesn't really support unions
As for unions, Trump doesn’t really support unions – what he supports is having union members support him. Whether it was his recent attack on UAW President Shawn Fain or his broadside against Richard Trumka, the late, highly respected AFL-CIO president, Trump has often sought to turn union members against their union leaders – a move that weakens unions and their ability to stand up to corporations and demand better pay and conditions.
In recent weeks, Trump has all but declared war on UAW leaders, saying that union members "are being sold down the river by their leadership."
Trump even called on union members to stop paying union dues, a statement that would only come from someone who wants to cripple unions rather than strengthen them. In a statement that UAW President Fain saw as a betrayal of workers, unions and the state of Michigan, Trump once recommended that auto plants in Michigan move to lower-wage states to remain competitive.
Trump actions favor corporations over unions
When nominating U.S. Supreme Court justices, Trump chose people who were far friendlier to corporations than to workers. One of his appointees provided the deciding vote in Janus v. AFSCME – the most important anti-union decision in decades.
This decision substantially hurt labor unions and their treasuries by ruling that teachers, police officers and other government employees could opt out of paying any dues whatsoever to the unions that fight for them and win raises for them. The 5-4 decision overturned a unanimous 1977 decision that was a victory for the Detroit teachers’ union, and made sure workers paid their fair share to their union.
Trump’s nominees to the National Labor Relations Board repeatedly favored corporations over unions, often acting in ways that made it harder for workers to unionize.
UAW to GM:Show me a Big 3 auto executive who'd work for our union pay
Trump deserves credit for making good on one promise he made to workers: that he’d fight hard on trade. He improved NAFTA, although, until House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi and labor unions stepped up the pressure, the changes he won had failed to ensure the agreement would have an effective enforcement mechanism to protect Mexican workers’ rights.
As for Beijing, Trump laudably stood up to China’s stealing our trade secrets and its improper subsidies to industry. But Trump’s go-it-alone, America-first strategy was less successful in pressuring China to mend its ways than it could have been if he had lined up powerful allies like Europe, Japan and Canada to join us.
Trump likes to boast that under him we had the best economy ever – something many other presidents, not to mention economists, would quarrel with.
Job growth, for instance, has been far slower under Trump than Biden. In Biden’s first 31 months in office, through this past August, the nation added 403,000 jobs a month on average; in Trump’s first 31 months, it added 181,000 a month (that was before the pandemic hit).
Workers shouldn’t be fooled. When Trump tells workers he has your backs, it’s like a fox telling the hens, "I have your backs."
Steven Greenhouse is a senior fellow at The Century Foundation, a think tank, and the author of the book, “Beaten Down, Worked Up: The Past, Present, and Future of American Labor.” This column first published in the Detroit Free Press.
veryGood! (25)
Related
- Cowboys owner Jerry Jones responds to CeeDee Lamb's excuse about curtains at AT&T Stadium
- Apple releases urgent update to fix iOS 17 security issues
- U.S. imposes sanctions on three Sudanese figures with ties to former leader Omar al-Bashir
- Sprawling casino and hotel catering to locals is opening southwest of Las Vegas Strip
- Where you retire could affect your tax bill. Here's how.
- In GOP’s proposed Georgia congressional map, a key question is which voters are legally protected
- Judges reject call for near ban on Hague prison visits for 3 former Kosovo Liberation Army fighters
- Israel strikes in and around Gaza’s second largest city in an already bloody new phase of the war
- Olivia Munn Says She “Barely Knew” John Mulaney When She Got Pregnant With Their Son
- ‘That's authoritarianism’: Florida argues school libraries are for government messaging
Ranking
- Powerball winning numbers for Nov. 9 drawing: Jackpot rises to $92 million
- UN agency cites worrying warming trend as COP28 summit grapples with curbing climate change
- Oxford picks rizz as the word of the year
- Musician Carl Mueller III fatally stabbed in Philadelphia: 'He was brilliant'
- AP Top 25: Oregon remains No. 1 as Big Ten grabs 4 of top 5 spots; Georgia, Miami out of top 10
- National Cookie Day 2023: How to get deals, freebies and even recipes to try at home
- Biden is spending most of the week raising money at events with James Taylor and Steven Spielberg
- 'Bachelor in Paradise' finale: How to watch the final episode of season 9, release date
Recommendation
-
Miami Marlins hiring Los Angeles Dodgers first base coach Clayton McCullough as manager
-
Minnesota, Wisconsin wildlife officials capture 100s of invasive carp in Mississippi River
-
Virginia officer seriously wounded in gunfire exchange that left stabbing suspect dead, police say
-
Supreme Court wrestles with legal shield for Sackler family in Purdue Pharma bankruptcy plan
-
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has a long record of promoting anti-vaccine views
-
Virginia officials certify 2023 legislative election results, other electoral contests
-
Teddi Mellencamp Fiercely Defends Kyle Richards Amid Costars' Response to Mauricio Umansky Split
-
Minnesota prosecutors won’t charge officers in the death of a man who drowned after fleeing police