Current:Home > StocksNot wearing a mask during COVID-19 health emergency isn’t a free speech right, appeals court says-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Not wearing a mask during COVID-19 health emergency isn’t a free speech right, appeals court says
View Date:2024-12-23 22:00:46
TRENTON, N.J. (AP) — A federal appeals court shot down claims Monday that New Jersey residents’ refusal to wear face masks at school board meetings during the COVID-19 outbreak constituted protected speech under the First Amendment.
The 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals issued a ruling in two related cases stemming from lawsuits against officials in Freehold and Cranford, New Jersey.
The suits revolved around claims that the plaintiffs were retaliated against by school boards because they refused to wear masks during public meetings. In one of the suits, the court sent the case back to a lower court for consideration. In the other, it said the plaintiff failed to show she was retaliated against.
Still, the court found that refusing to wear a mask during a public health emergency didn’t amount to free speech protected by the Constitution.
“A question shadowing suits such as these is whether there is a First Amendment right to refuse to wear a protective mask as required by valid health and safety orders put in place during a recognized public health emergency. Like all courts to address this issue, we conclude there is not,” the court said.
The court added: “Skeptics are free to — and did — voice their opposition through multiple means, but disobeying a masking requirement is not one of them. One could not, for example, refuse to pay taxes to express the belief that ‘taxes are theft.’ Nor could one refuse to wear a motorcycle helmet as a symbolic protest against a state law requiring them.”
The lawsuits were filed by George Falcone and Gwyneth Murray-Nolan.
Falcone attended a Freehold Township school board meeting in early 2022 when masks were still required. He refused, according to the court’s ruling, and was issued a summons on a trespassing charge. He also alleged a later school board meeting was canceled in retaliation for his not wearing a mask. A lower court found he didn’t have standing to bring the suit, and he appealed.
Murray-Nolan, who had testified before lawmakers on her skepticism toward the efficacy of masking, attended an early 2022 Cranford school board meeting without a mask despite a requirement for them. Less than a month later at the board’s next meeting, she was arrested on a defiant trespass charge after attending without a mask. A lower court found officers had probable cause to arrest her because she failed to wear a mask as required under the law at the time. She appealed.
A message seeking comment was left with the appellants’ attorney.
Eric Harrison, an attorney for the officials named in the suit, lauded the ruling on Tuesday. In an emailed statement he said that refusing to wear a mask in violation of a public health mandate “is not the sort of ‘civil disobedience’ that the drafters of the First Amendment had in mind as protected speech.”
New Jersey’s statewide order for public masking in schools ended in March 2022, shortly after the incidents described in the suits.
veryGood! (84331)
Related
- Shel Talmy, produced hits by The Who, The Kinks and other 1960s British bands, dead at 87
- NFL playoff picture Week 15: Cowboys tumble despite sealing spot, Bills surge
- Eagles replacing defensive coordinator Sean Desai with Matt Patricia − but not officially
- What is SB4? Texas immigration enforcement law likely to face court challenge
- Contained, extinguished and mopping up: Here’s what some common wildfire terms mean
- Maryland Stadium Authority approves a lease extension for the Baltimore Orioles at Camden Yards
- Hong Kong’s activist publisher to stand trial this week under Beijing’s crackdown on dissidents
- 3 dead, 1 hospitalized in Missouri for carbon monoxide poisoning
- 'Devastation is absolutely heartbreaking' from Southern California wildfire
- Southwest Airlines reaches $140 million settlement for December 2022 flight-canceling meltdown
Ranking
- How Ben Affleck Really Feels About His and Jennifer Lopez’s Movie Gigli Today
- Matt Rife doubles down on joke controversies at stand-up show: ‘You don't have to listen to it'
- A suspected cyberattack paralyzes the majority of gas stations across Iran
- People are leaving some neighborhoods because of floods, a new study finds
- 'Gladiator 2' review: Yes, we are entertained again by outrageous sequel
- Iowa dad charged after 4-year-old eats THC bar is latest in edible emergencies with children
- Revisiting 'The Color Purple' wars
- October 2023 in photos: USA TODAY's most memorable images
Recommendation
-
Patricia Heaton criticizes media, 'extremists' she says 'fear-mongered' in 2024 election
-
Author Masha Gessen receives German prize in scaled-down format after comparing Gaza to Nazi-era ghettos
-
Alex Batty Disappearance Case: U.K. Boy Who Went Missing at 11 Years Old Found 6 Years Later
-
Check the Powerball winning numbers for Saturday's drawing with $535 million jackpot
-
Beyoncé has released lots of new products. Here's a Beyhive gift guide for the holidays
-
Hostages were carrying white flag on a stick when Israeli troops mistakenly shot them dead in Gaza, IDF says
-
36 days at sea: How these castaways survived hallucinations, thirst and desperation
-
Behind the ‘Maestro’ biopic are a raft of theater stars supporting the story of Leonard Bernstein