Current:Home > MarketsAppeals court frees attorney from having to join, pay dues to Louisiana bar association, for now-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Appeals court frees attorney from having to join, pay dues to Louisiana bar association, for now
View Date:2024-12-23 16:41:18
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — A Louisiana lawyer who objected to the state bar association’s public statements on several issues including health tips and LGBTQ rights can no longer be forced to join or pay dues to the association, a federal appeals court has ruled.
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals order, dated Monday, blocks the Louisiana State Bar Association from forcing attorney Randy Boudreaux to join the LSBA or pay its dues, at least for now.
The ruling sends the case back to a federal district judge for further action. It appears to leave open the possibility that mandatory membership and dues could be imposed on Boudreaux, if the LSBA no longer takes public positions deemed “non-germane” to the regulation of the legal profession.
Boudreaux’s is one of more than two dozen cases playing out around the country challenging state requirements that attorneys join and pay dues to state bar associations. Organizations including the Goldwater Institute and, in Louisiana, the Pelican Institute, are challenging mandatory bar association membership as violations of free speech rights.
The 5th Circuit ruled in 2021 — in cases out of Louisiana and Texas — that mandatory bar membership can be seen as constitutional under current law and Supreme Court precedent if the bar association is engaged in funding or lobbying for activities that are germane to the regulation of the legal profession or improvement of legal services.
Since then, Monday’s ruling said, LSBA has failed to stay “in its constitutionally prescribed lane.”
“To its credit, the LSBA has stopped much of its objectionable activity,” Judge Jerry Smith wrote for the panel of three judges in the latest ruling. “But despite the LSBA’s scruples, Boudreaux has still identified some examples of non-germane speech.”
Non-germane statements included posts on Twitter — now known as X — on topics including the possible health benefits of walnuts, the need for exercise and the promotion of charitable events, and more contentious issues. The association’s promotion of an article on the effects of student loan debt on young lawyers was not germane, the court found. “If anything, the thrust of the article is backhanded support for student-debt relief, a nakedly political position,” Smith wrote.
The opinion also agrees with Boudreaux’s objections to the bar association promoting “a link to a History.com article about gay rights, along with a large rainbow flag icon that read “LGBT Pride Month.”
The association “can promote inclusion of LGBT individuals in the legal profession — we held that Texas could do that, even if was controversial,” Smith wrote. “But the LSBA may not promote LGBT causes generally, with no connection to the legal profession.”
The LSBA did not immediately respond to an emailed request for comment.
“I expect that the LSBA will argue that it won’t offend again if compulsory membership continues,” attorney Dane Ciolino, part of the legal team supporting Boudreaux, said in emailed statements. “But it has said exactly that before and thereafter failed to comply with the First Amendment.”
Smith was nominated to the 5th Circuit by former President Ronald Reagan. Also on the panel were Judge Carolyn Dineen King, nominated by former President Jimmy Carter, and Jennifer Walker Elrod, nominated by former president George W. Bush.
veryGood! (7)
Related
- Federal judge blocks Louisiana law that requires classrooms to display Ten Commandments
- Driver rescued after crashed semi dangles off Louisville bridge: She was praying
- New York man who fatally shot woman who was mistakenly driven up his driveway sentenced to 25 years to life in prison
- Philadelphia Eagles release trade-deadline acquisition Kevin Byard
- Glen Powell Addresses Rumor He’ll Replace Tom Cruise in Mission Impossible Franchise
- NCAA freezing investigations into third-party NIL activities after judge granted injunction
- Police in suburban Chicago release body-worn camera footage of fatal shooting of man in his bedroom
- Small plane crashes on golf course at private Florida Keys resort; 1 person injured
- College football top five gets overhaul as Georgia, Miami both tumble in US LBM Coaches Poll
- Firefighters face difficult weather conditions as they battle the largest wildfire in Texas history
Ranking
- Father, 5 children hurt in propane tank explosion while getting toys: 'Devastating accident'
- Caitlin Clark's scoring record doesn't matter. She's bigger than any number
- Kindness across state lines: Immigrants' kids in Philly are helping migrants' kids in Texas
- Andy Russell, star LB who helped turn Pittsburgh Steelers into champions, dies at 82
- Fantasy football waiver wire: 10 players to add for NFL Week 11
- Trump wins the Missouri caucuses and sweeps Michigan GOP convention as he moves closer to nomination
- The IRS is sending 125,000 compliance letters in campaign against wealthy tax cheats
- Babies born March 2 can get a free book for Dr. Seuss Day: Here's how to claim one
Recommendation
-
Get $103 Worth of Tatcha Skincare for $43.98 + 70% Off Flash Deals on Elemis, Josie Maran & More
-
Removed during protests, Louisville's statue of King Louis XVI is still in limbo
-
Texas Panhandle wildfires leave dead animals everywhere as agricultural commissioner predicts 10,000 dead cattle
-
Kindness across state lines: Immigrants' kids in Philly are helping migrants' kids in Texas
-
NFL power rankings Week 11: Steelers, Eagles enjoying stealthy rises
-
Christian Coleman edges Noah Lyles to win world indoor title in track and field 60 meters
-
Americans are saving less and spending more. Could that raise the risk of recession?
-
Why Victoria Beckham Is Stepping Out at Paris Fashion Week With Crutches