Current:Home > BackEnbridge Now Expects $55 Million Fine for Michigan Oil Spill-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Enbridge Now Expects $55 Million Fine for Michigan Oil Spill
View Date:2024-12-23 17:10:45
The potential fine Enbridge, Inc. expects for spilling more than 1 million gallons of tar sands oil into Michigan’s Kalamazoo River in 2010 continues to creep higher and now is estimated at $55 million.
The Canada-based company revealed the revised estimate earlier this week in a quarterly disclosure filing with the U. S. Securities and Exchange Commission. It cautions investors that the ultimate fine eventually imposed by the federal Environmental Protection Agency could cost the company even more.
The new figure offers a glimpse of the highly secretive and lengthy negotiations between Enbridge and the EPA and lawyers from the U.S. Department of Justice. In 2013, Enbridge estimated the fine would be $22 million. That figure jumped to $40 million last year. Those shifting numbers signal a resolution may be near, industry analysts say.
The penalty is for Clean Water Act violations surrounding the tar sands oil spill that fouled nearly 40 miles of the Kalamazoo River near Marshall, Mich. after its aging pipeline 6B ruptured nearly six years ago.
The spill triggered a massive cleanup effort that has cost the company more than $1.2 billion.
Before being asked by the EPA not to discuss the negotiations publically, Enbridge spokesman Michael Barnes said the EPA opened discussions last year with a proposed $85 million fine. That led to Enbridge to propose a $40 million fine and the EPA countered with $65 million, Barnes said.
But now, Barnes said he can no longer talk about the settlement discussions at the request of the EPA.
“We continue to meet with the DOJ and EPA to discuss possible settlement parameters,” he said. “The DOJ/EPA has bound us to confidentiality on the discussions.”
The EPA did not respond to requests for comment.
The $55 million figure represents the minimum fine the company expects, according to its SEC filing.
“Given the complexity of settlement negotiations, which we expect will continue, and the limited information available to assess the matter, we are unable to reasonably estimate the final penalty which might be incurred or to reasonably estimate a range of outcomes at this time,” the company said in the filing.
Enbridge also noted that the EPA could require it to institute programs such as enhanced monitoring of its pipelines that could add to its costs.
Andy Levine, a former EPA lawyer now in private practice in Philadelphia, said the disclosure of the $55 million figure indicates a settlement is near.
“This has been going on for some time now. So when you see the numbers getting closer and some movement by both sides, it tells me that a resolution is close at hand,” he said.
“This is not something that either side wants to go on forever.”
Enbridge and the EPA have twice agreed to extend the deadline for reaching a settlement.
“There comes a time when it has to be done so both parties can move on,” Levin said. “I think that’s what you’re seeing here. There have been two time extensions and the numbers are getting closer.”
Levin also said he believes Enbridge and the EPA want to avoid a lengthy and costly court battle.
“I’m not seeing a stalemate here,” he said. “It appears they want to keep this out of court.”
Enbridge already has been hit with millions in penalties. The company agreed to a $75 million fine from Michigan environmental officials and a $4 million settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice’s Environment and Natural Resources Division in 2014. The company also was tagged with a $3.7 million civil penalty by the U.S. Department of Transportation four years ago.
veryGood! (5712)
Related
- Will Reeve, son of Christopher Reeve, gets engaged to girlfriend Amanda Dubin
- Which country has the most Olympic medals of all-time? It's Team USA in a landslide.
- Read Obama's full statement on Biden dropping out
- New York Regulators Found High Levels of TCE in Kindra Bell’s Ithaca Home. They Told Her Not to Worry
- Katharine Hayhoe’s Post-Election Advice: Fight Fear, Embrace Hope and Work Together
- Peak global population is approaching, thanks to lower fertility rates: Graphics explain
- Eva Mendes' Ultimate Self-Care Hack May Surprise You
- Vice President Kamala Harris leads list of contenders for spots on the Democratic ticket
- Man is 'not dead anymore' after long battle with IRS, which mistakenly labeled him deceased
- Adidas pulls Bella Hadid ad from campaign linked to 1972 Munich Olympics after Israeli criticism
Ranking
- Justice Department sues to block UnitedHealth Group’s $3.3 billion purchase of Amedisys
- The Mitsubishi Starion and Chrysler conquest are super rad and rebadged
- LeBron James selected as Team USA male flagbearer for Paris Olympics opening ceremony
- Guns n' Roses' Slash Shares His 25-Year-Old Stepdaughter Has Died
- Candidates line up for special elections to replace Virginia senators recently elected to US House
- Judge Orders Oil and Gas Leases in Wyoming to Proceed After Updated BLM Environmental Analysis
- Looking for an Olympic documentary before Paris Games? Here are the best
- Curiosity rover makes an accidental discovery on Mars. What the rare find could mean
Recommendation
-
Spirit Airlines cancels release of Q3 financial results as debt restructuring talks heat up
-
Get 80% Off Banana Republic, an Extra 60% Off Gap Clearance, 50% Off Le Creuset, 50% Off Ulta & More
-
Pilot living her dream killed in crash after skydivers jump from plane near Niagara Falls
-
Kamala Harris says she intends to earn and win Democratic presidential nomination
-
Vogue Model Dynus Saxon Charged With Murder After Stabbing Attack
-
Is it possible to live without a car? Why some Americans are going car-free
-
12-year-old girl charged with killing 8-year-old cousin over iPhone in Tennessee
-
LSU cornerback Javien Toviano arrested on accusation of video voyeurism, authorities say